site stats

South Africa: Oscar Pistorius Sentence – You Might Not Like It, but It Is the Law


Barry and June Steenkamp, top, Oscar Pistorius, bottom-left, and Decide Thokozile Masipa, backside-right.


The six-yr sentence in opposition to disgraced Paralympian Oscar Pistorius for murdering his lady friend, Reeva Steenkamp, has sparked controversy. South Africans and the arena are break up over the equity of the sentence surpassed down By Means Of High Court Docket Choose Thokozile Masipa. Some really feel it is too lenient while others are of the view that justice has been served. The Conversation Africa’s politics and society editor, Thabo Leshilo, quizzed College of Cape City Law Researcher Rudo Chitapi on the topic.

Please put the sentence into viewpoint.

In South Africa courts have a large discretion to resolve sentences In An Effort To arrive at punishment that is not only fair and just. Punishment must Additionally accord with constitutional purposes of criminal sanction. These are looking for to make certain that sentences should not just retributive but also rehabilitative and restorative.

As A Result, while minimal sentence legislation in South Africa does prescribe that murder must carry a minimum sentence of 15 years’ imprisonment for a primary-time offender, courts have a wide discretion to deviate. That’s in keeping with the goal to be just where they in finding “substantial and compelling circumstances”.

In This case Choose Thokozile Masipa found (judgment nonetheless to be revealed) that the mitigating components outweighed the aggravating factors such that “big and compelling instances” had been deemed to be existing, which justified an imposition of a sentence of six years’ imprisonment.

Probably The Most key mitigating factors that played a task In This discovering was once Pistorius’ regret. He had made a few attempts at an apology to Reeva Steenkamp’s household. Additionally, Within The instant aftermath of the incident, he had pleaded to God and bystanders for the deceased’s life.

Is the six-yr sentence for murder ordinary?

Even If some people might feel that the six-year sentence is “too light” for homicide, Decide Masipa’s account of her determination adopted acknowledged and typical principles of sentencing Legislation in South Africa.

Discretion to come to a decision a sentence plays a large position in sentencing process. Nevertheless, courts have held that the discretion afforded to judicial officers in sentencing is to be exercised judicially. That Implies judges are to train their discretion properly and fairly.

Over The Years, courts have developed tips that provide a framework inside which their discretion is to be exercised. In An Effort To arrive at a judicially applicable sentence, courts must believe what in Law is often known as the “Zinn Triad” – the perfect stability between the non-public cases of the accused, the seriousness of the offence and the pursuits of society.

In The Pistorius case, Judge Masipa Indeed verified a well-considered and determined engagement with these factors. What’s perhaps most fascinating about her judgment is her engagement with the 0.33 leg of that triad. She selected to deal with the subject of public perception in additional element.

The Judge drew essential distinctions between public opinion, which is often canvassed in media shops, and the public interest, which courts are enjoined to believe.

She decidedly and rather emphatically found that No Longer simplest does public opinion play a limited role in sentence consideration but it surely best matters in so far as it is according to tips tried, examined and located to be related In The Court of Regulation. She was once emphatic:

Our courts are courts of Law, No Longer of public opinion. We must adjudicate without concern, favour or prejudice. Public opinion may be loud and chronic, But it will possibly play no role In This case.

However it would nonetheless be said that the defence gained a strategic litigation victory in making its representations about public perceptions in its handle to the Court Docket.

What now for Oscar Pistorius?

Decide Masipa did not stipulate a non-parole length in her sentence. Hence, with regards to the Legislation, he will be eligible for parole best when he has served at the least half of his sentence.

The way to Appeal the sentence is on hand to each the state and defence. What is apparent is that it’ll Not simply suffice to argue that Judge Masipa was unsuitable. Rather, for any Enchantment on sentence to succeed, it will should be shown that the Choose misdirected herself in exercising her discretion.

The misdirection will have to be of this sort of nature, level or seriousness that it demonstrates that the Decide did not exercise her discretion properly. Examples of such misdirection embrace cases during which the sentencing Court has overemphasised the personal cases of the accused over the seriousness of the offence.

It remains to considered whether or not the state or defence will take this up. However it’s clear that Enchantment courts are reluctant to disturb sentence findings of trial courts Within The absence of a cogent misdirection. The sentence must had been “obviously inappropriate” or “result in a sense of shock”.

In view of the revised verdict – the Supreme Court Docket of Enchantment put aside his earlier conviction for culpable homicide, discovering him responsible of homicide – and the necessities for Enchantment, it appears not going that the defence will Enchantment. The state, on the other hand, has time – 14 days – to take stock and decide whether to Appeal.

Sentencing hearings are distinctive in that they supply an opportunity to believe the complexities of deviance and illegal activity to which courts must be delicate. Indeed, in her conclusion, Choose Masipa rightly recounted that a “resolution of a sentence that satisfies every related interest is never straightforward”.

Disclosure remark

Rudo Chitapi does Now Not work for, consult, personal shares in or receive funding from any company or group that may take advantage of this article, and has disclosed no relevant affiliations beyond the tutorial appointment above.

Supply hyperlink

You must be logged in to post a comment Login

Widgetized Section

Go to Admin » appearance » Widgets » and move a widget into Advertise Widget Zone